Social Media Marketing Sucks, or Your License To Print Money
It would appear that I am completely incapable of just staying away and keeping my mouth shut.
There was an excellent guest post on Copyblogger about social media skepticism by Bob Hoffman. As we are pretty big fans of skepticism here at IttyBiz HQ, I figured I’d come on out and open my pie hole.
The premise of the post is that from a marketing standpoint, social media and the internet in general are not as interactive and social as we’re making them out to be.
“But for the vast majority of internet users – the ones who don’t have blogs and don’t have their own websites – it is mostly another passive medium. And it’s getting passiver.” (Anybody who uses a word like “passiver” is welcome to stop by for a beer any time they like.)
As people with something to sell, we really, really, really want to believe that it’s this oh-so-interactive place but sadly, we’re wrong.
“It is my contention that web interactivity is continuing to grow for most every function except marketing. It is my further contention that marketing on the web is evolving very much as marketing on TV evolved – people with stuff yelling at people with money.” Cue big ass red text.
People with stuff yelling at people with money.
Many will talk shit about this article. Several already have. But I think it’s dead on and I’ll tell you why.
Go find a blog. Any blog. This one will do. Read some of the comments. (Maybe not the ones on the Stompernet review, but any other post is fine.) See who’s there.
The people who are commenting — interacting — are other bloggers. Some of them are my competitors, some of them are nearly competitors, some of them will be competitors when they’re able to quit their day job and start their own home business. Some of them just like to come here and hang out because home business on the internet is a fucking lonely business.
They are never going to buy what I sell.
The people who buy what I have to sell are generally people I wouldn’t know if they wrote their name on a frying pan and hit me in the face with it.
They will come, they will buy, they will have their problem solved. I am very lucky in that many of my clients have become friends, but they didn’t start out that way.
(From a commentator, Aura Mae: “At this point it seems more like a circle-jerk than an effective method of interacting with potential clients.”)
“…the average consumer simply does not have the time or the inclination to have conversations with marketers. Most of them, wisely, don’t have conversations with their husbands. Why in the world would they want to have conversations with us?”
Do you want to sit around and have a beer with Dell? Smirnoff? Apple? (OK, maybe Apple.) Did you wake up this morning and say, “You know, I haven’t really connected with the people who are trying to sell me shit lately. Maybe I should start a conversation. A really deep and meaningful one”?
No. You’re going to buy your fucking vodka and go home and get drunk with your real friends.
Interacting is a social activity. Buying is a commercial activity.
People in interaction mode don’t like being sold to. People looking to buy something don’t want to sit around and chat. They do not want you to be their friend.
They want you to solve their problem.
From Graham Strong:
“The Internet has the capability of increasing that communication level. Although you don’t always hear a voice, you can play a game of chess a lot easier with your friend, watch a YouTube video, etc. Do all this *while* on the phone, and you increase your interactivity even more.”
Absolutely. Extremely interactive and cool. But when I’m playing chess with my blog pack, I’m not whipping out my credit card to buy whatever the banner ads are selling. I’m busy hanging out playing chess with my friends.
From Rick-with-no-url:
“Just because you can’t figure out a way to market to those audiences doesn’t mean they’re not interacting. It just means that maybe they don’t want to interact with someone trying to sell or pitch something to them, instead of honestly contributing to their conversation.”
From Hayes Thompson:
“The number of ‘harnessing the marketing power of social networks’ articles I read last year. Not one could say how. We all love passing around this viral or that link. But are they shifting product? I saw a Vodafone web page streaker the other day. Funny for 2 seconds but it did nothing to stop me signing another 18 month contract with my current network.”
Dead on. If I hear one more thing about harnessing the power of social media… well, I won’t say that in print.
The take-away point and the real way to make money online:
Theoretically, socializing and buying can go hand in hand. Practically, they don’t. Your real market doesn’t have a clue who you are. They don’t know you, let alone like you. They are not your friends. They are busy and stressed out and in need of a product or service and they don’t have time to sit around and talk to you. Stop trying to “harness the power of social media” and start solving problems. Solve real problems and you have a license to print money.
















