In my last post, I went through 25 signs that you may have an authority problem.

Today, I want to define authority.

Because “authority” is a word that gets (ahem) mighty charged in our weird little corner of the internet.

Let’s do this.

Here’s how I define authority. There’s two layers. Ready?

On the visible layer, authority is the power to credibly tell people what to do.

In parenting, it’s “clean your room”, “do your homework”, or “stop hitting your brother”.

In marketing, it’s “Click this” or “read this” or “try this” or “buy this”.

In teaching or coaching or “influencing”, it could be anything. “Use better verbs”, perhaps. “Look at your vision board every morning.” “Post three Notes a day.”

(Keen observers will see that these are all calls to action. The authority is the person “making the call”.)

Even our friends are sometimes authorities. They might tell you to stockpile beans, or get a Roomba, or DTMFA. (If you are young or old or don’t know what that means, it’s from Dan Savage’s advice column, and stands for “dump the motherfucker already”. Wanna talk about authority? Hot hell.)

That’s authority in practice. You say what to do, and your listener, or reader, or client, or student, or kid experiences that direction as credible. They may take your direction, or they may not. But you gave direction credibly. Congratulations, you win at authority.

Underneath that layer, though, is the less visible layer, the core of authority, and it’s the layer we’re talking about today. At its heart:

Authority is the willingness to take responsibility.

A good authority puts something inside their domain. They say, “This part is mine to guide.” They decide to make something their problem.

The crossing guard is an authority. She takes responsibility for getting you across the street.

Your marketing coach (hi!) is an authority. She takes responsibility for your marketing.

Your skincare influencer is an authority. She takes responsibility for what you put on your face.

The first (visible) component of authority is the instruction.

The second (invisible) component of authority is the responsibility.

It has always fascinated me that humans are so averse to authority. Most of us are basically responsible people. We like responsibility. We care about outcomes. We care about ethics and context and consent. We care about doing good work. We care about people. And we care about not stealing all our clients’ money and moving to Borneo in the night.

You’d think authority would be a natural fit for nearly all of us. And yet. Let’s just say there’s a reason everyone kinda threw up a little when they read yesterday’s post. (Actually, there are a few.)

So let’s get ugly and look at…

Five reasons good people avoid becoming authorities

See which, if any, apply to you.

1. You have turned “there is such a thing as bad authority” into “authority is bad.”

Most of us have encountered bad authority. Bad teachers. Bad doctors. Bad bosses. Bad prefects. Bad parents. Bad moderators. Bad people with clipboards and lanyards and absolutely no business being in charge of any room, at any time, ever.

Yup, bad authority exists. (Incidentally, bad shrimp exists, bad cars exist, and bad girlfriends exist. The number of things that have bad variants is limitless.)

But! Good authority also exists.

You have probably had good teachers, good doctors, good mentors, good leaders, good moderators, good coaches, good editors, good instructors, good pastors, good crossing guards, good Brownie leaders, and good people at the front of the room who knew where the chairs should go.

And I’m going to go out on a limb here to suggest that you have had far more good authorities in your life than bad ones. Yes, certain politicians make anarchy very appealing. But taking bad examples and using them to damn an entire category is a very expensive mistake to make.

There are bad teachers, bad healers, and bad pastors. But I don’t want to live in a world with no teachers, healers, or pastors.

It appears, then, that good people are going to have to suck it up and take charge of something. Sigh if you must, but it has to be done.

2. You confuse “power” with “abuse of power”.

One of the things that comes with some types of authority is power.

Granted, most types of authority don’t have much power, but they do have some. The crossing guard lady can only really blow a whistle very hard. The corrupt cafeteria-lady-on-the-take is limited to giving you less meatloaf.

But yes, there is some power in authority. And our little leftist, nervous-system-dominant part of the internet tends to flip its collective shit about power. Because power can be abused.

Let me make something very, very clear.

Having power is not abusing power. Having power is not abusing power for the same reason that having a dog is not abusing a dog.

“Having” and “abusing” are VERY DIFFERENT VERBS.

Power is capacity. Influence. Leverage. The ability to affect an outcome. We LOVE power.

We love power all the time… when we trust the person using it. We love the pilot having power over the airplane. We love the surgeon having power in the operating room. We love the teacher having power in the classroom. We love the crossing guard having power at the intersection.

Yes, sometimes power is misused or abused or corrupted. Sometimes power can be a real problem. Power becomes a problem when it is unbounded, unaccountable, dishonest, inflated, hidden, or used outside its proper domain.

The solution to this is… don’t be an asshole.

Be bounded. Be accountable. Tell the truth. Stay in your domain. Let people leave. Make clear recommendations. Keep clean edges around what you can and cannot promise.

That is a much more useful plan than somehow trying to become a person with no power.

Assholes are bad. Red Bull is good. Power is neutral. And we all need to calm down.

3. You don’t trust your judgment enough to risk being wrong in public.

Putting ourselves in a position of authority puts our judgment on the line, and this makes almost everyone nervous. Directing people can be terrifying.

If I say, “Send the email at 7 am,” I signed off on that. The buck stops here.

If I say, “Cut the first module,” that cut has my name on it.

And if I say, “Raise the price,” and your sales go down by 81%? Now you’re out fifty grand and that’s on me.

This is a vulnerable place to be. A lot of people avoid that vulnerability by staying in the more comfortable realm of explanation.

Explanation is safer than direction. If I just tell you how a launch works, I’m not on the hook for nothin’. I can just say “Here are some factors to consider” and phew, the buck stops somewhere else.

You need enough earned trust in your own judgment to say, “Given what I know, given what I see, given what I believe, here is what I recommend.” That’s the job. If you can’t do that in the domain you are teaching, then you shouldn’t be teaching.

If you don’t trust yourself, you gotta deal with that before you expect other people to trust you. Sorry. I don’t make the rules.

4. You don’t want to make it a hierarchy.

This one is especially common in our tree-hugging hippie part of the world.

People want everything to feel collaborative. Horizontal. Mutual. Co-created. Peer-based. One big beautiful circle of everyone bringing their wisdom to the center.

There are places where that is lovely.

There are also places where people are paying you because they want someone at the front of the room.

When I go to church, I want a pastor. I want someone on the little platform. With a microphone. Who has prepared something. Who knows where we are going. Who has taken responsibility for the next hour of my life. I do not want a speaking circle every Sunday.

When I take a class, I want a teacher. When I hire a strategist, I want them to make a strategy. When I buy a course, I want the person who made the course to know why lesson two comes before lesson three.

People are not paying $200 an hour to be your equal partner. They are paying you because, in this domain, for this purpose, you can see something, decide something, teach something, or direct something that they cannot reliably do alone yet.

That creates a hierarchy. It’s a limited hierarchy. It’s a temporary hierarchy. It’s a consent-based and domain-specific hierarchy.

Still a hierarchy.

Trying to erase that hierarchy makes the client or student carry too much weight. It makes them decide what matters. It makes them infer your recommendation. It makes them figure out which part of your diffusely offered expertise to obey.

That may feel more equal to you, but it is less useful to them.

Sometimes the responsible move is to stand at the front of the room and say, “Start here.”

5. You are waiting for authority to be given, instead of taking it.

This may be the most common one.

Many people are waiting for someone to tell them it is their turn. That it’s time to stand at the front of the room and tell people what to do.

This is because we’re used to institutions, and in institutional settings, responsibility is assigned or bestowed. The school gives you the classroom. The church gives you the pulpit. The hospital gives you the patient. The city gives you the stop sign and the orange vest.

Someone says, “This is your domain. Please take responsibility for it, starting now.”

In independent work, nobody is coming with the clipboard. You are no longer given responsibility. You now have to take responsibility.

Not take like theft. Take like “taking” a number at the deli counter. “Taking” a plate of sushi off the conveyor belt. “Taking” a grape off a vine.

You walk over and say, “That’s mine now.”

Like those Christmas trees with tags on them for families who can’t afford presents.

Boy, 8. Girl, 10. Likes dinosaurs. Wants art supplies.

You walk over and “take” the tag. Now that family’s Christmas is, in a small but very real way, your problem. You have “taken” responsibility for your part.

You’ve said, “I will use my judgment, my resources, my taste, my effort, my discernment, and my available information to do right by this person.”

Authority, for our purposes, is like that… but with your readers, listeners, clients, patients, students, and workshop participants.
You take the tag and say, “This part is mine now.”

Then you make the recommendation. You name the habit. You decide what comes first. You say what matters first. You stick your neck out.

If you wait for authority to arrive before you practice authority, you will be waiting a very long time. Because in independent work, authority is exercised before it’s granted.

You become the art teacher by saying, “Wash your brushes.”

You become the strategist by saying, “Run it at 7 am.”

You become the guide by saying, “Start here.”

That is authority.

And it is yours for the taking.

xx
Naomi